A political storm has erupted in Jammu and Kashmir after Congress state president Tariq Hameed Karra suggested that two Special Police Officers (SPOs) killed in Kishtwar may have died not at the hands of terrorists but in firing by the Army, which allegedly mistook them for militants. The BJP has accused him of dishonouring the “martyrs” and, in effect, handing the perpetrators a clean chit.

Speaking to reporters in Srinagar, Karra said he had spoken to the Congress district president of Kishtwar. According to him, the two SPOs had gone hunting in civilian clothes and were carrying guns. “In that area, Warwan and its adjoining area, there were two pickets. While going, they crossed both pickets comfortably. However, when they were returning, because of their civilian dress, the Army mistook them for terrorists and fired upon them,” he said.
![]()
Karra also said that only the BJP was propagating the version that the two SPOs had been killed by terrorists. He did not wait for the findings of any official inquiry before putting forward his account, which relied on a party functionary’s version.
Karra did call the Kishtwar incident “condemnable, whoever may have committed it,” and demanded a thorough investigation, saying that “many questions are being raised about it.” However, he stopped short of describing the killings as a terror attack.

“An insult to their sacrifice”
The BJP responded sharply. Leader of Opposition in the Jammu and Kashmir Assembly Sunil Sharma accused Karra of spreading “misleading information” to shift blame from terrorists to the security forces, and demanded an unconditional apology.
“Rashpal Kumar and Babi Chand were not out hunting, as Karra claimed. They were SPOs on duty with the SOG, travelling to an Army post at Dharna-Marwah to relieve the jawans posted there. Calling two martyrs hunters is an insult to their sacrifice and to their grieving families,” Sharma said.
Rejecting the mistaken-identity claim, Sharma said the terrorists had taken away the SPOs’ rifles, magazines and ammunition. This, he argued, was inconsistent with the theory that the men were hunters shot by security forces.
Charge of double speak
Sharma also pointed to what he called Congress’s double speak. He said Karra had cited the same killing as proof of terrorism on November 14, only to blame security personnel a day later.

“Spreading hearsay on a terror killing is not politics, it is irresponsibility. The terrorists who killed Rashpal Kumar and Babi Chand could not have asked for a better cover story than the one Congress has given them. Pakistan’s propaganda machine will now quote a Congress state president to defame the Indian Army,” he said.
Questions over deployment
Sharma had earlier questioned the circumstances in which the two SPOs were sent across difficult mountainous terrain to assist Army personnel. He alleged that the decision exposed them to unnecessary risk and ultimately cost them their lives, and he questioned the operational strategy of the police officers who deployed them.

Sharma demanded that Karra immediately withdraw his remarks and apologise to the families of the slain SPOs, the Jammu and Kashmir Police and the Indian Army. He also asked the Congress leadership to clarify whether it stood with the security forces or with “Karra’s rumour.”
“The people of Jammu and Kashmir stand firmly with our forces. The terrorists behind this cowardly act will be hunted down and brought to justice,” he said.




